$20.00
We will hold your cart for 15:00.
WeatherTech is the name everyone knows when it comes to protecting your car's interior. Their custom-fit floor liners, cargo trays, and phone mounts are practically legendary among American car enthusiasts. But let's be honest: that reputation comes with a premium price tag. A single WeatherTech floor liner can set you back $150 or more, and their phone mounts aren't cheap either.
So, what if you want solid protection without emptying your wallet? Or maybe you just want a different look? The good news is that there are plenty of alternatives that offer similar functionality at a fraction of the cost. In this guide, we'll compare WeatherTech's most popular products—floor mats, seat covers, cargo liners, and phone mounts—against worthy competitors from BDK, Motor Trend, and Leader Accessories. We'll break down the pros and cons, help you decide where to splurge and where to save, and ultimately answer the question: is WeatherTech worth it?
Your phone is your lifeline while driving—for navigation, music, and hands-free calls. A good phone mount is essential, but do you need to spend over $60 for one? The WeatherTech CupFone is a cup-holder mount that's famous for its rock-solid grip and adjustable base. It fits a wide range of cup holders (we'll dive into that below) and holds your phone securely, even on bumpy roads. Plus, it's made in the USA and backed by WeatherTech's excellent warranty.
However, if you're not ready to spend that much, there are solid alternatives from brands like Beam Electronics, Mpow, or even simple magnetic mounts that cost under $20. But wait—in this article, we're focusing on brands available at Cabin Craft Auto. So let's see what we have.
Actually, looking at our catalog, we don't carry a budget cup-holder mount from BDK or Motor Trend. But we do have the WeatherTech DeskFone, which is a desktop version—not what you need for your car. So, for phone mounts, if you want the best in-car experience, the CupFone is your only mount option here. But let's be real: it's worth it. It's adjustable, secure, and doesn't block your charging port. It's a premium product that solves a common problem—your phone sliding around or falling out of cheap mounts.
One thing to check before buying: does the CupFone fit your cup holder? The base expands to fit cup holders from 2.75 to 3.75 inches in diameter, which covers most vehicles. But measure yours to be sure.
Floor mats are where WeatherTech really shines. Their custom-fit FloorLiners hug every contour of your vehicle's carpet, providing unbeatable protection against mud, snow, and spills. But they're pricey—often $150+ for a front set. If you're on a budget, you can get excellent all-weather mats from Motor Trend or BDK that offer 90% of the protection for a fraction of the price.
Motor Trend FlexTough Deep Dish Mats are a popular choice. They're trim-to-fit, so you can customize them to your vehicle. They feature deep channels that trap water and dirt, and they're made from heavy-duty rubber that's easy to clean. At around $33 for a set, they're a steal. The only downside? They're not custom-fit, so you might have gaps at the edges, and they may not stay in place as well as WeatherTech's, but they come with anti-slip backing.
BDK ProLiner Mats are another great option. These are also trim-to-fit, and they feature a raised lip that contains spills. They're made from durable rubber and come in a beige color that matches many interiors. At around $31, they're even cheaper than Motor Trend's. However, they don't have the deep dish design of the FlexTough, so they might not hold as much liquid.
So, which should you choose? If you're driving a brand-new car and want the absolute best protection, and you can afford it, go with WeatherTech. If you're driving an older car, or you just want good, cheap protection, Motor Trend or BDK are excellent choices. They're easy to trim and install, and they'll save you a ton of money.
Seat covers protect your seats from spills, stains, pet hair, and wear and tear. WeatherTech doesn't really make seat covers—they focus on floor liners and cargo liners. So, you're automatically looking at alternatives.
BDK PolyPro Seat Covers are a full set that covers both front and rear seats. They're made from a durable polyester material that's water-resistant and easy to install. They come in a charcoal color that looks sharp. At around $32, they're an incredible value. Just be aware that they may not fit perfectly on all vehicles, and they don't have cutouts for side airbags (though they're designed to be compatible, you should check your vehicle's airbag location).
Motor Trend AquaShield Rear Seat Cover is a great option if you only need to protect your back seat—maybe you have kids or pets. It's designed for split bench seats (60/40), which is common in trucks and SUVs. It's completely waterproof, making cleanup a breeze. At around $38, it's a smart investment.
Leader Accessories Bel-Air Seat Cover is a stylish choice if you want a faux leather look. It comes in black with a carbon fiber pattern and is available as a 2-piece set (front seats only). It's not custom fit, but it's universal and can be trimmed if needed. At $36, it's a bit more expensive than BDK, but the look is sportier.
When choosing seat covers, think about what you need: full coverage vs. just the back, material preference, and whether you have side airbags. All these options are affordable, so you can mix and match.
If you carry gear, groceries, or pets in your trunk or cargo area, a cargo liner is a must. WeatherTech's custom-fit cargo liners are fantastic—they fit like a glove and offer full coverage. But again, they're pricey, often over $100. If you want a universal solution, BDK makes a heavy-duty rubber cargo mat that you can trim to fit. It's 46" x 56.75", giving you plenty of coverage for most SUVs and trunks. At $39.59, it's a bargain. It has a raised lip to contain spills and a textured surface to keep items from sliding.
The downside? It's not custom-fit, so you may have gaps around the edges, and it may not stay perfectly flat. But for the price, it's a great option. Plus, it's made from heavy-duty rubber that's easy to clean—just hose it off.
So, is WeatherTech worth it? It depends on what you're buying.
Splurge on WeatherTech for:
Save money with alternatives for:
In the end, it's all about your budget and your priorities. WeatherTech is a premium brand that delivers on quality, but the alternatives we've highlighted offer great value for the money. So, assess your needs, consider your vehicle, and choose confidently.
